Domain Dispute is no longer news unless a Madonna or
Julia Roberts type of celebrity gets involved. However, greater now than
ever is the risk for domain registrants to lose their domain names when
they get involved in a domain dispute. The risk is originated from the
Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (the Policy) approved by ICANN and the
Anticybersquatting Consumer Protection Act (ACPA) passed by U.S. Congress.
The direct risk comes from reverse domain hijackers, biased panelists,
and the unprepared registrants themselves.
Innocent registrants are prone to ignoring measures to
protect their domain names. They tend to think they are safe and would
win even if some party would complain to WIPO-the worst arbitration organization
for innocent registrants. Thus, they often do not take steps to protect
their domain names. As a consequence, they are likely to lose their domain
name(s) in a domain dispute. Preparation both BEFORE and AFTER you receive
a complaint is equally important. Generic domain names are no exception.
Net-firms.com (usid.com
received a complaint from
netfirms.com) and netlearning.com
(the registrant received a complaint from NetLearning, Inc.) are just
two examples proving how easy it is for a common word domain name to get
hijacked.
The following suggestions may be useful when preparing
yourself for a potential battle for your domain name(s).
1) Make sure your domain record, including the ownership
and administrative contact information, is complete, correct, and current.
If it is incorrect, the panelists will take it as evidence against you.
Therefore, check your domain record often to see if any change is made
without your authorization.
2) Write down your idea or business plan about what you
would use your domain for and get it notarized.
3) If possible, register your domain name, i.e., yourdomainname.com,
as a trademark with the trademark authority in your country. If you registered
your domain name as a trademark successfully, it is to your advantage.
Once you establish your rights to your domain name(s), your domain name
is entitled to legal protection even if it is stolen.
4) If you start up a business, register and or use your
domain name as your business name, if possible. Use your domain name with
the TM sign on your letterhead, envelope, business card, or wherever possible.
When you design your web site, make sure to put the TM sign with your
domain name. Print a copy and have it notarized by a local Notary Public.
If your site is designed by others, make sure to get a certificate that
shows your domain name on it.
5) When you do advertising, make sure your domain name
shows up in the ad. If you do online advertising, even with
goto.com, print a copy of your link ad that is properly dated. Keep
a copy of that ad and all communications between you and your ad service
provider as evidence.
6) If you are not planning to use your domain name in
the near future, register it as an intent-to-use trademark with your trademark
authority. For coveted domain names, i.e., mostly single worded and popular,
yet generic names, you may not be able to get them registered as a trademark.
For those domain names, use them as soon as possible for any legitimate
purpose, such as for business, non-profit, or even a personal or fun activity.
7) When using a domain name, try to use a fee-based web
hosting service that would enhance the impression of seriousness of your
business. Free web hosting is costly because it will harm your business
in various ways.
8) Never merely put simple links on the pages and never
link your domain to porn sites. By doing so, you will be doomed if you
come across some self-authorized or puritan panelists.
9) If you consider selling your domain, do not sell it
until you establish your rights to it. When you receive any offer to purchase
your domain name, do not answer unless you know who the person is. The
inquirer may be a spy. Again, talk to a lawyer if possible before you
do anything.
10) When challenged directly by a company or individual,
you should never answer until you consult a legal professional. Any of
your good-willed answers may be used as evidence against you later or
help your challenger to shape a plan against you. Do not put out a web
site for your domain in a hurry as a response to the challenge you receive.
Such an action may prompt some panelists to believe you have done some
thing wrong.
11) When you receive a complaint from WIPO, you should
RESPOND if you want to defend your domain name(s). Many panelists would
treat you lightly and rule in favor of the complainant if you fail to
respond. If your domain name is critically important and you are well
financed, hire a COMPETENT lawyer! The fee can be anywhere between $1500
and $5000 per response. Or, some lawyers will charge on an hourly basis,
usually between $200 and $500 per hour. Do some searching and ask for
references when you choose a lawyer. Furthermore, you should consider
paying $1500 to have a three-panelist panel. With WIPO, you are likely
to lose if only one panelist is assigned to your case. When you request
three panelists, you have the right to designate one panelist for the
dispute panel. By carefully choosing a registrant-friendly panelist, you
will increase your likelihood of winning.
12) If you lose at WIPO, you have 10 days to appeal to
your local federal court or the court that has jurisdiction over the registrar.
13) If the challenger goes directly to court to sue you, you should file
your response timely. Do not get scared because the plaintiff may do this
simply as a tactic to scare you by the fact that a court action is more
expensive than dispute arbitration. The most important thing is to establish
your rights to your domain name. Keep any and all evidence that is indicative
of your using your domain name for a legitimate activity. And finally,
be careful to avoid the traps that would endanger your rights to your
domain names.
The tips in this article are intended for reference only
and should not be construed as legal advice.